← Decision Library
Business
Introduce a paid tier to a free product with an active user base
Short-term — weeks to months
Context
The product has real users and genuine engagement. Monetization hasn't started yet. Adding a paid tier could convert power users into paying customers — but it risks fragmenting the community and slowing organic growth if it lands wrong.
Goal
Decide whether the business is ready to monetize, and whether the structure of a paid tier actually fits the way users currently show up.
Analysis dimensions — pre-configured
Reversibility55
Upside Potential75
Downside Severity40
Downside Likelihood35
Dependency Risk30
Long-Term Alignment80
Sky bars indicate dimensions working in the decision's favor. Gray bars highlight areas of elevated risk or cost.
Run this scenario through the full structured analysis — blindspots, second-order risks, and a complete Decision Strength Index.
Run this analysis →Free · pre-loaded with this scenario · takes about 2 minutes